Opinion: Don’t want to send the kids back to school? Why not try unschooling at home?
The following opinion piece co-authored by Dr Karleen Gribble, Adjunct Associate Professor from the School of Nursing and Midwifery, was first published online with The Conversation (opens in a new window).
As schools resume for most Australian students, a new group of parents have emerged.
These parents have decided to give home education a longer term try, finding their children have improved academically and benefited from the calmer home learning environment.
This change may mean some families move to a more child-led way of learning. This approach can be described as unschooling – an informal way of learning that advocates student-chosen activities rather than teacher-directed lessons.
Unschoolers learn through living and are in charge of their own education. Students have the freedom to learn through a variety of means including play, household tasks and personal interests, as well as work experience, travel, books, elective classes, mentors and social interactions.
Sometimes the name unschooling leads people to believe children aren’t being educated or taught anything at all. But unschooling allows children to explore and learn in their own way. It’s a different form of education to that of schools, but it can work extremely well.
During the coronavirus shutdown, schools were providing schoolwork for children to do at home. Some suggested they just focus on the basics, which left plenty of time spare.
Some families found online learning wasn’t working for their children and negotiated with teachers about alternate ways of meeting learning outcomes.
Many parents improvised their children’s education. And so they were unschooling, even if they didn’t know it by name.
Who invented unschooling?
Unschooling is an educational philosophy developed in the 1960s by theorists including John Holt and Ivan Illich.
Their ideas, particularly around children exercising the liberty to choose the direction of their learning, are becoming increasingly popular in educational research.
Illich and Holt said traditional schooling could confuse the creation of a product – such as a test result – with learning. They argued learning is a process, not an end point.
While such ideas may seem radical, Holt was building on a well recognised foundation of educational philosophy: that children learn best when the learning is meaningful and accessible to them.
A typical day unschooling
In unschooling, parents work with their children to meet their educational goals.
This means they support their children’s interests and associated learning. They recognise the learning inherent in life activities and may enrich it via conversation or direction to other sources.
At the heart of unschooling is a belief that, in a rich and stimulating environment, children cannot not learn.
There’s actually no typical unschooling day, as what happens depends on the family and child. In unschooling families, any interest may form the basis of learning.
For example, an interest in dinosaurs may trigger a series of activities, such as:
- children read books and write stories about dinosaurs (Literacy)
- they measure the size of lizards and compare them to dinosaurs (Numeracy)
- they explore how dinosaurs died out (Science)
- they consider how dinosaurs may have influenced our culture, such as with dragons (Humanities and Social Sciences)
- they watch Jurassic Park to see how dinosaurs are represented in film (the Arts).
Children may talk with their peers about their love of dinosaurs and use this as an opportunity for socialisation. They may need a lot of assistance from a parent to do this or may explore on their own.
Everyday activities such as cooking, cleaning, gardening and shopping can also be learning opportunities. Benign neglect, leading to boredom, provides an opportunity for children to discover new interests and activities (and for parents to get some of their own work done).
How do students get assessed?
Unlike in school, unschooling assessment happens on a daily basis, through observing the children’s experiences. Parents may compile photographs or scrap books of their children’s learning experiences and keep them as records.
But many unschooolers will do formal assessment for careers that need certification. They may also do tests in line with university aspirants who do not come straight from school. Or they may go straight to TAFE or study via Open University, both of which don’t need formal test results for entry.
Unschooled students often do very well at university. For example, in the US, unschoolers are sought after by prestigious institutions including Brown, Cornell and Columbia.
One study of 75 unschooled adults found 83% had gone on to some form of formal education after school, and most were “gainfully employed and financially independent”.
Research suggests unschoolers’ success may come down to an intrinsic motivation to learn that’s been fostered through their unschooling experiences.
Evidence of unschooling in the lockdown
During the coronavirus crisis, if your children alternated their schoolwork with other study based on their needs and interests, they were unschooling.
If you went for a walk and identified plants or animals, and discussed them, that was unschooling. Cooking and decorating a sibling’s birthday cake was unschooling.
Discovering your children’s interest in Ancient Egypt and then watching documentaries about the subject was unschooling.
If your child decided to read the whole Harry Potter series in a week, that was unschooling.
It’s entirely possible to unschool and still meet the government curriculum requirements.
In fact, the Singaporean education minister, Ong Ye Kung, effectively recommended unschooling when he said students should take advantage of their time away from school to “learn outside the syllabus, read widely, be curious, find your passions”.
Children following this advice may have benefited, rather than been disadvantaged, from their break from formal learning. For some, continuing home-based learning may be advantageous.
Each state and territory has a legislative framework which allows parents to home educate their children. Support is available from experienced home educators online and through home education support groups.
20 May 202
Western Sydney University researchers will explore interventions for young men and boys surrounding the use of Intimate Partner Violence (IPV) following a $292,457 grant from the Family Violence Research Program.
Opinion: An autism minister may boost support and coordination. But governments that follow South Australia’s lead should be cautious
This week, the South Australian government announced the appointment of Emily Bourke to the role of assistant minister for autism. It’s the first portfolio of its kind in Australia.
Western Sydney University welcomes the announcement of an additional 20,000 places for universities to help address national skills shortages and boost higher education participation.